Fata Morgana (chimerically) wrote,
Fata Morgana
chimerically

  • Mood:

history and objectivism

This was an interesting read about the alleged actions by the government leading up to the prisoner abuse in Iraq.

Here's another interesting article about India, by Arundhati Roy, an author I admire.

I'm frustrated by the usual questions of: how much of this is true? What's still unknown? How does the journalist have access to all of these memos and documents anyway? And if this all is true, how can anyone remain on the pro-government side of the fray without implicitly sanctioning illegal torture/abuse?

Furthermore, how different is this from other conflicts? Why isn't it also front-page news that various governments that the U.S. supports in South America and elsewhere are fascist? What can I believe, anyway?

Interesting as the above article is, there's no way for me to evaluate the veracity of the claims in it. The most frustrating thing about this is that there is an objective truth. One version of all that I've been reading about actually did happen. That makes it so much more frustrating than arguing about religion, ethics, or other matters of opinion. History seems like it should be scientific, but it isn't replicable.
Subscribe

  • Permanent accounts

    LJ is having a permanent account sale until June 28 -- and if you get an account in the next few hours (the first 36 of the sale), they'll donate…

  • upcoming ballroom events: competition and charity ball

    My next competition, after a whole quarter with none (thankfully, given how crazily busy I've been), is the regional championships next Saturday,…

  • news alert for Bay Area residents

    Woa -- the eastbound 580 section of The Maze, which goes from the Bay Bridge to the 580, collapsed onto the section that connects the 80 to the 880…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 0 comments